diff --git a/.agentguard/squads/hq/em-report.json b/.agentguard/squads/hq/em-report.json index bd391081..d4496b9b 100644 --- a/.agentguard/squads/hq/em-report.json +++ b/.agentguard/squads/hq/em-report.json @@ -1,31 +1,41 @@ { "squad": "hq", - "generatedAt": "2026-03-31T04:48:00.000Z", + "generatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", "identity": "claude-code:unknown:planner (hq:em)", "runCycle": "3h", "health": "red", - "healthReason": "Three P0 blockers persist: worker pool dead (#1402, cycle 12), codex budget exhausted (#1431, cycle 7 — auto-resolves 2026-04-03), swarm health crisis (#1452, cycle 3). Version drift: agentguard-cloud 2.10.1 (10th cycle, P0); agentguard-analytics version discrepancy discovered — actual version is 2.7.3 (3+ minor versions behind, previous reports were WRONG, P1). Governance systemic issues from #1462 remain unresolved by kernel-squad/hq-ops (cycle 2).", - "summary": "Productive cycle. Merged 9 PRs: kernel-em #1497, dependabot #1484–#1491 (actions/checkout v6, deploy-pages v5, codeql-action, setup-go v6, re2js, typescript-eslint, turbo, MCP SDK). Closed stale marketing-em PR #1455 after 3 CONFLICTING cycles. Triaged 5 new Preflight protocol issues (#1492–#1496, kernel squad, P2–P3). CORRECTION: agentguard-analytics is on 2.7.3 not 2.10.2 — previous EM reports were reading wrong source. Circuit breakers (#1335) auto-closed. Security alerts (#1449) resolved by PR #1469. Sprint goal on track: Go kernel→Cloud E2E (due Apr 17). KE-2 shipped, KE-8 complete, KE-9 assigned (PR #1497 merged).", + "healthReason": "Four P0 blockers active: worker pool dead (#1402, cycle 13), codex budget exhausted (#1431, cycle 8 — auto-resolves 2026-04-03), swarm health crisis (#1452, cycle 4), NEW: main-tree toolchain broken 30 dangling symlinks (#1467, cycle 1 — 22h unresolved). NEW P1 sprint-blocker: telemetry default URL unreachable blocks Go→Cloud E2E validation (#1477). Version drift persists: agentguard-cloud 2.10.1 (11th cycle), agentguard-analytics 2.7.3.", + "summary": "This cycle (04:48Z→07:13Z): merged 3 EM cycle PRs (#1499 site-em, #1500 studio-em, #1501 kernel-em — all green). Triaged 5 untriaged issues: #1477 (P1 telemetry URL broken, sprint-blocking), #1478 (P2 Go fast-path skips cloud telemetry, sprint-relevant), #1476 (P1 better-sqlite3 cluster #3), #1482 (P2 CLI not in PATH), #1483 (P2 MCP policy-as-guidance). Escalated #1467 (NEW P0: 30 dangling symlinks main-tree toolchain break — human action: pnpm install --force). Sprint concern: #1477+#1478 together mean Go→Cloud E2E telemetry pipeline cannot be validated until fixed.", "sprintStatus": { "goal": "Validate Go kernel→Cloud telemetry E2E pipeline (workspace #60, due Apr 17). KE-2 SHIPPED. KE-8 COMPLETE. KE-9 IN PROGRESS.", "issues": [1402, 1403, 1431, 1452, 1462], + "sprintBlockers": [ + { + "issue": 1477, + "title": "Telemetry default URL unreachable — events silently dropped", + "priority": "P1", + "note": "Sprint-blocking: Go→Cloud E2E cannot be validated without reliable telemetry. Fix fallback URL or document required .env setup." + }, + { + "issue": 1478, + "title": "Go fast-path allow-decisions produce zero cloud telemetry", + "priority": "P2", + "note": "Sprint-relevant: dashboard underreports workload. Critical for May 6 demo accuracy." + } + ], "resolvedThisSprint": [1427, 1430, 1335, 1449], "nearResolution": [ { "issue": 1431, "note": "Codex budget auto-resolves 2026-04-03 (3 days)" - }, - { - "issue": 1402, - "note": "Worker pool blocked on human action (jpleva91 must run server/deploy.sh). Cycle 12." } ] }, "ciStatus": { - "agentGuard": "green", - "agentguardCloud": "green (CI passes; systemic exit=1 agent failures are runtime/policy mismatch with version 2.10.1)", + "agentGuard": "green (CI passes; main-tree toolchain broken due to #1467 dangling symlinks — risk: fresh build will fail on cache miss)", + "agentguardCloud": "green (CI passes; systemic exit=1 agent failures are runtime/policy mismatch with version 2.10.1 — 11th cycle)", "agentguardAnalytics": "unknown", - "recentMerges": "PR #1497 (kernel-em KE-9), #1484 (checkout v6), #1485 (deploy-pages v5), #1486 (codeql-action), #1487 (setup-go v6), #1488 (re2js), #1489 (typescript-eslint), #1490 (turbo), #1491 (MCP SDK). All merged this cycle.", + "recentMerges": "PR #1499 (site-em), #1500 (studio-em), #1501 (kernel-em). All green, merged this cycle.", "securityAlerts": { "count": 0, "status": "RESOLVED — PR #1469 patched path-to-regexp and brace-expansion (#1449 closed)." @@ -37,84 +47,95 @@ "agentguardCloud": "2.10.1", "agentguardAnalytics": "2.7.3", "drift": { - "agentguardCloud": "2 patches behind (P0 — 10th consecutive cycle, CRITICAL. Cloud systemic failures are likely caused by policy/config mismatch with older version.)", - "agentguardAnalytics": "3+ minor versions behind (P1 — CORRECTION: previous EM reports incorrectly stated 2.10.2. Actual root package.json shows 2.7.3. Requires urgent upgrade investigation.)" + "agentguardCloud": "2 patches behind (P0 — 11th consecutive cycle, CRITICAL. Cloud systemic failures almost certainly caused by version/policy mismatch.)", + "agentguardAnalytics": "3+ minor versions behind (P1 — actual version confirmed 2.7.3. Director must prioritize upgrade investigation.)" } }, "prQueue": { "agentGuard": { "open": 0, - "mergedThisCycle": [1497, 1484, 1485, 1486, 1487, 1488, 1489, 1490, 1491], - "closedThisCycle": [ - { - "number": 1455, - "title": "chore(marketing-em): EM cycle 2026-03-30T20:00Z", - "reason": "CONFLICTING for 3 consecutive EM cycles — no rebase activity. Closed with comment requesting fresh PR." - } - ] + "mergedThisCycle": [1499, 1500, 1501], + "closedThisCycle": [] } }, "newIssuesTriaged": [ { - "number": 1492, - "title": "[kernel] MCP server enforcement layer for Preflight protocol", - "priority": "P3 / priority:low", + "number": 1477, + "title": "bug(telemetry): default fallback URL 'telemetry.agentguard.dev' unreachable", + "priority": "P1", "squad": "kernel", - "note": "Post-v1 nice-to-have. Gate on Preflight v1 adoption." + "sprintRelevant": true, + "note": "Sprint-blocking: Go→Cloud E2E cannot be validated without reliable telemetry. Fix fallback URL or document required .env setup." }, { - "number": 1493, - "title": "[kernel] Integrate Preflight protocol into AgentGuard governance hooks", - "priority": "P2 / priority:medium", + "number": 1478, + "title": "feat(telemetry): Go fast-path skips cloud telemetry — allow decisions invisible", + "priority": "P2", "squad": "kernel", - "note": "Key integration bridge between Preflight protocol and AgentGuard mechanical enforcement. Depends on Preflight v1 shipping." + "sprintRelevant": true, + "note": "Sprint-relevant: dashboard underreports workload. Critical for May 6 demo accuracy." }, { - "number": 1494, - "title": "[kernel] Preflight Protocol JSON schema for machine-readable validation", - "priority": "P3 / priority:low", + "number": 1476, + "title": "bug(telemetry): better-sqlite3 native bindings missing from global pnpm install", + "priority": "P1", "squad": "kernel", - "note": "Belongs primarily in the preflight repo. Needs refinement for scope." + "note": "Part of better-sqlite3 cluster (#1463, #1471, #1476). Likely caused by #1467 dangling symlinks." }, { - "number": 1495, - "title": "[kernel] State Witness — re-validate conditions at execution time", - "priority": "P2 / priority:medium", + "number": 1482, + "title": "[dogfood] start-governance-runtime skill fails — CLI not present in worktrees", + "priority": "P2", "squad": "kernel", - "note": "Addresses TOCTOU gap in propose→execute lifecycle. Important correctness/security concern." + "note": "DX issue: agentguard CLI not in PATH in bench-devs-platform worktrees. Workaround: node_modules/.bin/agentguard." }, { - "number": 1496, - "title": "[kernel] Risk-gated write lifecycle — draft/review/execute for tool calls", - "priority": "P2 / priority:medium", + "number": 1483, + "title": "feat(mcp): add policy-as-guidance tools to MCP server", + "priority": "P2", "squad": "kernel", - "note": "Architecturally significant: 3-stage lifecycle replaces binary risk threshold. KE-9 or KE-10 candidate." + "note": "KE-10 backlog candidate. Gate on KE-9 completion." } ], "blockers": [ + { + "issue": 1467, + "description": "P0 NEW (cycle 1, 22h unresolved): 30 dangling node_modules symlinks in main tree — vitest, eslint, tsc, prettier, esbuild, turbo, better-sqlite3, tsx all broken. Fix: pnpm install --force in agent-guard/. Likely root cause of better-sqlite3 cluster (#1463, #1471, #1476).", + "escalatedTo": "human (jpleva91)", + "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T09:12:21Z", + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 1 + }, { "issue": 1402, - "description": "P0: Worker pool dead on jared box. 12+ cycles, swarm frozen. Human must run server/deploy.sh.", + "description": "P0: Worker pool dead on jared box. 13+ cycles, swarm frozen. Human must run server/deploy.sh. #1481 corroborates: queue backlog 110, copilot agents starved.", "escalatedTo": "human (jpleva91)", - "escalationCount": 12 + "firstSeen": "2026-03-29T19:00:00.000Z", + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 13 }, { "issue": 1431, "description": "P0: Codex budget exhausted until Apr 3. 25+ agents offline. Auto-resolves 2026-04-03T02:25Z.", "escalatedTo": "human + director", - "escalationCount": 7 + "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T00:02:00.000Z", + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 8 }, { "issue": 1452, - "description": "P0 (cycle 3): 69.5% agent failure rate, 26 orphaned vitest processes (~3.3GB RAM), cloud-squad 74.3% exit=1. Human must kill zombies + prune worktrees. Cloud-squad must upgrade to 2.10.3.", - "escalatedTo": "human (zombie kill + worktree prune) + director (cloud systemic) + cloud-squad (upgrade)", - "escalationCount": 3 + "description": "P0 (cycle 4): 69.5% agent failure rate, 26 orphaned vitest processes (~3.3GB RAM), cloud-squad 74.3% exit=1. NEW CONTEXT: #1467 (dangling symlinks) may be root cause of better-sqlite3 failures. Human actions still pending: kill zombies + prune worktrees + pnpm install --force.", + "escalatedTo": "human (zombie kill + worktree prune + pnpm install --force) + director (cloud systemic) + cloud-squad (upgrade 2.10.3)", + "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T06:06:00.000Z", + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 4 }, { "issue": 1462, - "description": "P1 (cycle 2): Governance report — 5 HIGH systemic issues: agent identity 99.9% missing, gh CLI false positive, team compliance broken, no-secret-exposure dormant, policy gaps. Kernel-squad and hq-ops have assignments.", + "description": "P1 (cycle 3): Governance report — 5 HIGH systemic issues: agent identity 99.9% missing, gh CLI false positive, team compliance broken, no-secret-exposure dormant, policy gaps.", "escalatedTo": "kernel-squad + hq-ops", - "escalationCount": 2 + "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T21:00:00.000Z", + "escalationCount": 3 }, { "issue": 1403, @@ -125,13 +146,13 @@ ], "crossRepoCoordination": { "versionSync": { - "agentguardCloud": "BLOCKED — 10th cycle. Cloud-squad must upgrade agentguard.yaml + package.json to 2.10.3. This is almost certainly causing the 74.3% exit=1 systemic failures.", - "agentguardAnalytics": "CORRECTION: actual version is 2.7.3 (root package.json). Previous EM reports incorrectly showed 2.10.2. Director should prioritize analytics upgrade plan." + "agentguardCloud": "BLOCKED — 11th cycle. Cloud-squad must upgrade agentguard.yaml + package.json to 2.10.3.", + "agentguardAnalytics": "BLOCKED — actual version 2.7.3 confirmed. Director must prioritize upgrade investigation." } }, "dogfoodPatterns": [ { - "pattern": "No governance denials encountered during this EM session (persona write, PR merges, issue edits all passed through).", + "pattern": "No governance denials encountered during this EM session (persona write, PR merges, issue edits, state file writes all passed through).", "severity": "info", "status": "nominal" }, diff --git a/.agentguard/squads/hq/state.json b/.agentguard/squads/hq/state.json index 18e966d5..ddba8b54 100644 --- a/.agentguard/squads/hq/state.json +++ b/.agentguard/squads/hq/state.json @@ -1,32 +1,32 @@ { "squad": "hq", "sprint": { - "goal": "Validate Go kernel→Cloud telemetry E2E pipeline (workspace #60, due Apr 17). KE-2 SHIPPED. KE-8 COMPLETE. KE-9 IN PROGRESS (#1497 merged). Version sync. ShellForge coordination.", + "goal": "Validate Go kernel→Cloud telemetry E2E pipeline (workspace #60, due Apr 17). KE-2 SHIPPED. KE-8 COMPLETE. KE-9 IN PROGRESS. NEW SPRINT BLOCKERS: #1477 (telemetry URL) + #1478 (Go fast-path telemetry gap).", "issues": [1402, 1403, 1431, 1452, 1462] }, "assignments": { "human-jpleva91": { - "task": "P0 URGENT (cycle 12): (1) Run server/deploy.sh on jared box (#1402). (2) Kill 26 zombie vitest processes (~3.3GB RAM per #1452): ps aux | grep 'cloud-qa-257589|cloud-sr-1428111|tier-c-copilot-implementer-1127453' | grep vitest | awk '{print $2}' | xargs kill. (3) Prune stuck worktrees: git worktree prune && rm -rf .worktrees/marketing-em-3815251 .worktrees/octi-pulpo-sr-3847600 .worktrees/octi-pulpo-qa-3847601. (4) Governance: read issue #1462 (5 HIGH items from 65,830 session analysis).", + "task": "P0 URGENT (cycle 13/1/4): (1) Run server/deploy.sh on jared box (#1402). (2) Kill 26 zombie vitest processes (#1452): ps aux | grep 'cloud-qa-257589|cloud-sr-1428111|tier-c-copilot-implementer-1127453' | grep vitest | awk '{print $2}' | xargs kill. (3) Prune stuck worktrees: git worktree prune && rm -rf .worktrees/marketing-em-3815251 .worktrees/octi-pulpo-sr-3847600 .worktrees/octi-pulpo-qa-3847601. (4) NEW P0: Fix 30 dangling node_modules symlinks (#1467): cd /home/jared/agentguard-workspace/agent-guard && pnpm install --force. (5) Read #1477 + #1478 — sprint-blocking telemetry issues.", "priority": "P0" }, "director": { - "task": "P0: #1431 codex budget exhausted until Apr 3 (cycle 7) — auto-resolves. P0: Cloud squad 74.3% systemic exit=1 failures (10th cycle 2.10.1 vs 2.10.3) — cloud-squad must upgrade. P1 NEW: agentguard-analytics is actually on 2.7.3 (not 2.10.2 as previously reported) — needs upgrade investigation. P2: ShellForge squad owner (#1362-#1367). P2: #1177 pr-merger-agent policy gap.", + "task": "P0: #1431 codex budget exhausted until Apr 3 (cycle 8) — auto-resolves. P0: Cloud squad 74.3% systemic exit=1 failures (11th cycle 2.10.1 vs 2.10.3) — cloud-squad must upgrade. P1: agentguard-analytics on 2.7.3 — needs upgrade investigation. P2: ShellForge squad owner (#1362-#1367). P2: #1177 pr-merger-agent policy gap.", "priority": "P0" }, "cloud-squad": { - "task": "P0 (10th cycle — CRITICAL): Upgrade agentguard-cloud to 2.10.3 immediately. Add octi-pulpo allow rule to agentguard-cloud/agentguard.yaml. Investigate systemic exit=1 failures (cloud-sr 96.2%, cloud-em 73.7% per #1452). Upgrade very likely fixes policy version mismatch.", + "task": "P0 (11th cycle — CRITICAL): Upgrade agentguard-cloud to 2.10.3 immediately. Add octi-pulpo allow rule to agentguard-cloud/agentguard.yaml. Investigate systemic exit=1 failures (cloud-sr 96.2%, cloud-em 73.7% per #1452). Upgrade very likely fixes policy version mismatch.", "priority": "P0" }, "kernel-squad": { - "task": "P1 (from #1462, cycle 2): (a) Fix gh CLI false positive in destructive command scanner. (b) Investigate no-secret-exposure sev5 dormancy. (c) Fix session-to-agent attribution join. (d) Add explicit git.reset deny + npm.publish rule to agentguard.yaml. P2 NEW: Triage #1495 (State Witness) and #1496 (Risk-gated lifecycle) for KE-9 or KE-10 scope. P2 NEW: #1493 (Preflight integration) — gates on Preflight v1 ship. P2: Fix #1177.", + "task": "P1 SPRINT: Fix #1477 (telemetry default URL unreachable — events silently dropped, sprint-blocking). P2 SPRINT: Fix #1478 (Go fast-path allow-decisions produce zero cloud telemetry — dashboard data gap for May 6 demo). P1: Fix better-sqlite3 cluster (#1463, #1471, #1476) — likely resolved by #1467 fix. P1 (from #1462, cycle 3): (a) Fix gh CLI false positive in destructive command scanner. (b) Investigate no-secret-exposure sev5 dormancy. (c) Fix session-to-agent attribution join. (d) Add explicit git.reset deny + npm.publish rule to agentguard.yaml. P1: Resolve #1473 (no-governance-self-modification blocks EM squad state writes). P2: Triage #1495 (State Witness) and #1496 (Risk-gated lifecycle) for KE-9 or KE-10. P2: #1493 (Preflight integration). P2: Fix #1177. P2: #1482 (CLI not in PATH). P2: #1483 (MCP policy-as-guidance, KE-10 backlog).", "priority": "P1" }, "hq-ops": { - "task": "P1 (from #1462, cycle 2): Add AGENTGUARD_AGENT_NAME export to scripts/write-persona.sh output and all agent schedule configs. 99.9% sessions lack identity — team observability completely dark. NOTE: This cycle's EM persona shows 'unknown' model field — confirms the issue.", + "task": "P1 (from #1462, cycle 3): Add AGENTGUARD_AGENT_NAME export to scripts/write-persona.sh output and all agent schedule configs. 99.9% sessions lack identity — team observability completely dark. NOTE: This cycle's EM persona shows 'unknown' model field — confirms the issue.", "priority": "P1" }, "ops": { - "task": "#1403: readybench QA swarm non-operational 5+ days. Depends on #1402 resolution.", + "task": "#1403: readybench QA swarm non-operational 5+ days. Depends on #1402.", "priority": "P1" }, "marketing-em": { @@ -118,39 +118,65 @@ "priority": "P1", "resolvedAt": "2026-03-31T04:48:00.000Z", "note": "PR #1497 merged this cycle." + }, + "site-em-pr-1499": { + "task": "Site-em EM cycle PR — site green, CHANGELOG gap P2", + "priority": "P3", + "resolvedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "note": "PR #1499 merged this cycle." + }, + "studio-em-pr-1500": { + "task": "Studio-em EM cycle PR — squad state update", + "priority": "P3", + "resolvedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "note": "PR #1500 merged this cycle." + }, + "kernel-em-pr-1501": { + "task": "Kernel-em EM cycle PR — escalate #1473, KE-9 design-phase nudge", + "priority": "P2", + "resolvedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "note": "PR #1501 merged this cycle." } }, "blockers": [ + { + "issue": 1467, + "description": "P0 NEW (cycle 1, 22h unresolved): 30 dangling node_modules symlinks in main tree — full toolchain broken. Fix: pnpm install --force in agent-guard/.", + "escalatedTo": "human (jpleva91)", + "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T09:12:21Z", + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 1 + }, { "issue": 1402, - "description": "P0: Worker pool dead on jared box. 12+ cycles, swarm frozen. Human must run server/deploy.sh.", + "description": "P0: Worker pool dead on jared box. 13+ cycles, swarm frozen. Human must run server/deploy.sh.", "escalatedTo": "human (jpleva91)", "firstSeen": "2026-03-29T19:00:00.000Z", - "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T04:48:00.000Z", - "escalationCount": 12 + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 13 }, { "issue": 1431, "description": "P0: Codex budget exhausted until Apr 3. 25+ agents offline. Auto-resolves 2026-04-03T02:25Z.", "escalatedTo": "human + director", "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T00:02:00.000Z", - "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T04:48:00.000Z", - "escalationCount": 7 + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 8 }, { "issue": 1452, - "description": "P0 (cycle 3): 69.5% agent failure rate, 26 orphaned vitest processes (~3.3GB RAM), cloud-squad 74.3% exit=1 systemic failures, 3 stuck worktrees.", - "escalatedTo": "human (zombie kill + worktree prune) + director (cloud systemic) + cloud-squad (upgrade 2.10.3)", + "description": "P0 (cycle 4): 69.5% agent failure rate, 26 orphaned vitest processes (~3.3GB RAM), cloud-squad 74.3% exit=1. Human must kill zombies + prune worktrees + pnpm install --force.", + "escalatedTo": "human (zombie kill + worktree prune + pnpm install --force) + director (cloud systemic) + cloud-squad (upgrade 2.10.3)", "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T06:06:00.000Z", - "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T04:48:00.000Z", - "escalationCount": 3 + "escalatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z", + "escalationCount": 4 }, { "issue": 1462, - "description": "P1 (cycle 2): Governance report — 5 HIGH systemic issues: agent identity 99.9% missing, gh CLI false positive, team compliance broken, no-secret-exposure dormant, policy gaps.", + "description": "P1 (cycle 3): Governance report — 5 HIGH systemic issues: agent identity 99.9% missing, gh CLI false positive, team compliance broken, no-secret-exposure dormant, policy gaps. Kernel-squad and hq-ops have assignments.", "escalatedTo": "kernel-squad + hq-ops", "firstSeen": "2026-03-30T21:00:00.000Z", - "escalationCount": 2 + "escalationCount": 3 }, { "issue": 1403, @@ -161,10 +187,10 @@ ], "prQueue": { "open": 0, - "reviewed": 9, - "mergedThisCycle": 9, - "closedThisCycle": 1, - "notes": "Merged #1497 (kernel-em KE-9), #1484-#1491 (dependabot: checkout v6, deploy-pages v5, codeql-action, setup-go v6, re2js, typescript-eslint, turbo, MCP SDK). Closed #1455 (marketing-em stale)." + "reviewed": 3, + "mergedThisCycle": 3, + "closedThisCycle": 0, + "notes": "Merged #1499 (site-em), #1500 (studio-em), #1501 (kernel-em). All had green checks." }, - "updatedAt": "2026-03-31T04:48:00.000Z" + "updatedAt": "2026-03-31T07:13:10Z" }