Problem with LUX data

[ue71603]

Data download from

    "url":"https://data.public.lu/fr/datasets/horaires-et-arrets-des-transport-publics-netex/",
    "download_url":"https://data.public.lu/fr/datasets/r/e3c3f7b2-7867-451c-84fd-91f6d939c37e",

Stops without coordinates:

csvRowNumber (?)The row number of the faulty record.	locationType (?)The faulty record's stops.location_type.	stopId (?)The faulty record's id.
508	"STOP"	"LU::ScheduledStopPoint:8045547_CFL_::"
2951	"STOP"	"LU::ScheduledStopPoint:8046696_CFL_::"
3646	"STOP"	"LU::ScheduledStopPoint:8025147_CFL_::"

[skinkie]

Does a PSA assignment exist for the Quay with coordinates?

[ue71603]

in the original data? or in the database?

[skinkie]

The original.

[ue71603]

Ok. Will check. There is another issue: They use AuthorityRef also in StopPlace. The Ref survives to the result, but the one Authority only used in there, is not included in the EPIP. I can just remove it for now in the input with the preprocessor. But I guess this is a flaw in the software. What do you think?

[ue71603]

Example

            <StopPlace id="LU::StopPlace:500000167_CdT::" version="1767075111">
              <Name>Trier, Pallien</Name>
              <Centroid>
                <Location>
                  <Longitude>6.630269</Longitude>
                  <Latitude>49.764167</Latitude>
                </Location>
              </Centroid>
              <TopographicPlaceRef ref="LU::TopographicPlace:255::" version="1767075111"/>
              <Locale>
                <TimeZone>Europe/Berlin</TimeZone>
              </Locale>
              <AuthorityRef ref="LU::Authority:1::" version="1767075111"/>
              <StopPlaceType>other</StopPlaceType>
              <quays>
                <Quay id="LU::Quay:500021601_MM_CdT::" version="1767075111">
                  <Name>Trier, Pallien</Name>
                  <Centroid>
                    <Location>
                      <Longitude>6.630269</Longitude>
                      <Latitude>49.764167</Latitude>
                    </Location>
                  </Centroid>
                </Quay>
              </quays>

            <PassengerStopAssignment id="LU::PassengerStopAssignment:26664::" order="106" version="1767075111">
              <ScheduledStopPointRef ref="LU::ScheduledStopPoint:8045547_CFL_::" version="1767075111"/>
              <StopPlaceRef ref="LU::StopPlace:500000167_CdT::" version="1767075111"/>
              <QuayRef ref="LU::Quay:500021601_MM_CdT::" version="1767075111"/>
            </PassengerStopAssignment>

            <ScheduledStopPoint id="LU::ScheduledStopPoint:8045547_CFL_::" version="1767075111">
              <Name>Trier-Pallien</Name>
              <Location/>
              <StopType>railStation</StopType>
            </ScheduledStopPoint>

So it is not a LUX problem. It is a badger problem in the GTFS transform. In NeTEx it is done ok

[skinkie]

I think the software should have added the Authority in the added GeneralFrame. If that part does not work, it is a bug. If the Authority has never been defined, that is a bug in the publication.

I would argue that we could implement a "fixer" that would remove all unresolved references.

[ue71603]

The Authority is in the file:
here in the import data base:

then it gets lost in conv.epip_db_to_db.py.

Easiest way would Authority to be copied. In most cases this is harmless anyhow and not too big a burden?

I try it now.

[skinkie]

It should not be required to do it manual. It is my bug :-)