pdfdol resources

[thorwhalen]

To collect resources that could be useful for further pdfdol dev.

[thorwhalen]

Validating PDF

What tools do we have to be able to validate PDFs? Of course, the most basic would be to see if the bytes are even readable by a PDF renderer. This is limited though. Often when using tool to generate PDF things get jumbled a bit or the layout a bit screwy (like parts of the content running off the page). So we would like to see what other tools might be available to test for such features. At the other end of the spectrum, given the recent advances in AI, we probably have intelligent, visual analyzer at our disposal as well.

The following is just some quick research into some of these tools, and related questions (such as "should we feed a pdf or an image thereof to AI to analyze?".

PDF vs. Image for AI Analysis

When deciding whether to provide a PDF or an image of a PDF to an AI agent for layout validation, an image is generally a better choice. While many modern AI models can read and "see" PDF files, providing an image converts the PDF content into a visual format that is immediately understandable for an AI trained on visual data. This is crucial for layout analysis because the AI can directly observe the positioning, spacing, and alignment of elements, which are the very things that can get "jumbled" during generation. PDF files, on the other hand, are complex documents that contain text, vectors, and embedded objects in a structured way. An AI that processes a PDF might focus on the underlying data rather than the visual rendering, potentially missing subtle layout issues.

Tools to Convert PDF to an Image

To programmatically convert a PDF to an image for an AI agent, you can use a Python library. Two popular and effective options are:

• PyMuPDF (fitz): This is a fast and feature-rich library that excels at rendering PDF pages into various image formats. It's an excellent choice for its performance and control over the rendering process, including setting resolution (DPI).
• pdf2image: This library is a popular choice for its simplicity. It works by wrapping poppler, a C++ rendering library, and handles the conversion of PDF pages into Python Imaging Library (PIL) objects, which you can then save as images.

Third-Party Tools for PDF Validation

While an AI agent can perform a visual check, there are specialized tools, both with and without AI, that offer more robust and automated PDF validation.

Visual Regression Testing Tools (AI-Powered)

These tools are designed to detect visual changes and are excellent for catching layout issues. They take a "golden" or "baseline" snapshot of a correct PDF and compare it against a newly generated one. They often use AI to intelligently ignore minor, non-critical differences like anti-aliasing or slight pixel shifts, focusing only on meaningful layout changes.

• Applitools: A leading platform for visual testing that can be used to validate PDFs. Its AI-powered "Visual AI" can perform smart comparisons that are less prone to false positives.
• Functionize: This tool uses computer vision and machine learning to verify files visually, including PDFs. It can detect and highlight visual discrepancies.
• pdf-visual-diff: An open-source JavaScript library that uses pdf.js to convert PDFs to PNGs and jimp for image comparisons. It's a great option for integrating into a CI/CD pipeline.

---

PDF Accessibility and Standards Validation Tools

These tools go beyond visual layout and check the underlying structure of the PDF to ensure it conforms to standards. This is critical for readability and accessibility, as it ensures the document can be properly read by screen readers and other assistive technologies. While they don't directly validate the visual layout, a well-structured PDF is less likely to have jumbled content.

• veraPDF: An open-source validator that checks PDF files for compliance with the PDF/A standard, which is designed for long-term digital preservation.
• PAC (PDF Accessibility Checker): A free and user-friendly tool that checks a PDF against accessibility standards like PDF/UA and WCAG. It provides detailed reports on issues like missing tags, improper headings, and lack of alt text for images, all of which impact readability and structure.
• PAVE: An online tool that validates and can even automatically fix PDF accessibility issues without altering the visual layout.

[thorwhalen]

Structuring/Parsing/Segmenting PDFs

Tool Name & URL	Relevant Functionality for Structuring	Popularity & Maintenance
pdfminer.six	The foundation for layout analysis. Extracts text while providing location, font, and size information (the visual cues needed to infer structure).	High Popularity, Actively Maintained. It's the most active fork of the original PDFMiner, with a strong community.
pdfplumber	Built on pdfminer.six. Optimized for structured data extraction. Offers fine-grained access to characters, lines, and rectangles and features robust table extraction.	High Popularity, Actively Maintained. Excellent for table-heavy or coordinate-based extraction tasks.
PyMuPDF (fitz)	Extremely fast C-based library (Python bindings) that provides access to blocks of text with bounding box coordinates (layout information). The related pymupdf4llm can generate surprisingly clean Markdown output.	Very High Popularity, Actively Maintained. Valued for its high speed and performance.
Nougat (OCR)	A Vision Transformer model specifically for academic documents. Performs OCR to convert scientific papers, including complex LaTeX math and tables, directly into a Multi-Markdown (.mmd) format.	High and Growing. Developed by Meta (Facebook Research). Best-in-class performance for scientific/academic PDFs, but requires a large model download.