Layer 3: Judgement Event System

[yungcero]

Discussion for integration of a possible Layer 3 authorization layer - either separate as layer 3 or integrated into Layer 2

[yungcero]

@schchit

[yungcero]

I think that the Judgement Event System is something that can go into the authorization process of AIP. What are your thoughts on the standardization of how Human Judgement can be integrated into agent approval and standardized?

[schchit]

I believe the identity layer is indispensable for the future, and the work AIP is doing is highly valuable and essential. At the same time, I think the JEP responsibility layer will also be very important going forward. I sincerely hope that both of us have the opportunity to become standardized protocols. Recently, I've been engaging with the EU and Singapore, and I believe we can have in-depth discussions on how to collaborate and maximize our joint value — any approach or form of cooperation is open for discussion. 发自我的iPhone

…

------------------ Original ------------------ From: James ***@***.***> Date: Fri,Mar 13,2026 6:56 PM To: openagentidentityprotocol/agentidentityprotocol ***@***.***> Cc: JEP (Judgment Event Protocol) ***@***.***>, Mention ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [openagentidentityprotocol/agentidentityprotocol] Layer 3:Judgement Event System (Discussion #17) I think that the Judgement Event System is something that can go into the authorization process of AIP. What are your thoughts on the standardization of how Human Judgement can be integrated into agent approval and standardized? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[schchit]

Additionally, regarding the idea you brought up, I have no issue with it and I fully support it. Feel free to let me know whenever you need me to assist.

…

------------------ Original ------------------ From: James ***@***.***> Date: Fri,Mar 13,2026 6:56 PM To: openagentidentityprotocol/agentidentityprotocol ***@***.***> Cc: JEP (Judgment Event Protocol) ***@***.***>, Mention ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [openagentidentityprotocol/agentidentityprotocol] Layer 3:Judgement Event System (Discussion #17) I think that the Judgement Event System is something that can go into the authorization process of AIP. What are your thoughts on the standardization of how Human Judgement can be integrated into agent approval and standardized? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[yungcero]

Would you want to work on a spec on how the Judgement fits into the Layer 2? Then we can add it to our specs and documentation too. I see a Judgement Event happening during the catch of a tool by the AIP proxy layer. I think from you we can see 1) spec integration 2) building it into the aip-playground as an implementation example

[schchit]

I think the Layer 2 idea is a good one. I suggest we start with Layer 3 — we can align with your interface standardization needs on our side. Then, after about 6 months, we can revisit the discussion and explore whether progressing to Layer 2 makes sense. This approach gives both sides time to polish the stability of each protocol and explore their respective boundaries.

By the way, are you attending IETF 125 in Shenzhen? If so, it would be great to meet in person and chat. Hope everything goes well with you!

[yungcero]

Ok great, let's do a Layer 3 then. We can add it into our documentation spec an additional spec, have you had the chance to look at our website? Also sadly not but will be giving a small presentation at the side meeting that's remote today! https://github.com/ietf-dmsc/125meeting/blob/main/Agenda.md

[schchit]

Glad we're aligned on Layer 3. We'll start adapting to the interface you define.
I actually took a look at your website a week ago, and I'll spend more time studying it carefully. Feel free to reach out anytime—if you have any needs regarding the interface definition, just let me know.

[schchit]

Quick update: HJS has been renamed to JEP (Judgment Event Protocol)—same protocol, clearer focus on the event layer.