Skip to content

Commit 203b894

Browse files
committed
docs: integrate Infrastructure Testing Strategies across redesign documentation
- Enhanced phase2-analysis/04-testing-strategy.md with infrastructure testing approaches * Infrastructure Testing-Driven Development (TDD) methodology * testcontainers-rs architecture for container-based testing * Multi-stage testing pipeline with performance targets * Rust async testing integration with tokio and comprehensive examples - Enhanced phase2-analysis/02-automation-and-tooling.md with Rust testing framework * Comprehensive async testing with tokio (parallel execution, timeouts, resource management) * CLI testing integration patterns with clap and comprehensive test examples * Error handling strategies with anyhow/thiserror for robust testing * testcontainers-rs integration examples for infrastructure deployment testing - Added container-based-testing-architecture-adr.md as architectural decision record * Container-based testing architecture using testcontainers-rs * Multi-stage testing pipeline: static validation (<30s), unit tests (<1min), container integration (1-3min), E2E (5-10min) * Parallel test execution strategies with tokio async capabilities * Comprehensive error handling patterns and 4-phase implementation strategy * Detailed rationale for hybrid VM+container testing approach This integration establishes a comprehensive testing architecture foundation combining fast container-based feedback with thorough VM-based validation, leveraging Rust's async capabilities for optimal performance and reliability.
1 parent 4b7caa4 commit 203b894

File tree

4 files changed

+621
-6
lines changed

4 files changed

+621
-6
lines changed

docs/redesign/phase2-analysis/02-automation-and-tooling.md

Lines changed: 125 additions & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -199,4 +199,128 @@ approach for the redesign is:
199199
- **Infrastructure**: OpenTofu/Terraform
200200
- **Configuration Management**: Ansible
201201
- **Services**: Docker Compose
202-
- **Automation**: Simplified orchestration with proper error handling
202+
- **Automation**: Rust-based CLI with proper error handling
203+
204+
### Rust Testing Framework Integration
205+
206+
For comprehensive infrastructure testing, the redesign should leverage Rust's robust
207+
testing ecosystem:
208+
209+
**Async Testing with tokio**:
210+
211+
- **Parallel Execution**: Multiple test suites run concurrently using async/await
212+
- **Timeout Management**: Built-in timeout handling for network operations
213+
- **Resource Management**: Automatic cleanup with async Drop implementations
214+
- **Performance**: Efficient handling of I/O-bound infrastructure operations
215+
216+
**CLI Testing Integration**:
217+
218+
```rust
219+
#[cfg(test)]
220+
mod cli_tests {
221+
use std::process::Command;
222+
use tempfile::TempDir;
223+
224+
#[tokio::test]
225+
async fn test_deploy_command_dry_run() {
226+
let temp_dir = TempDir::new().unwrap();
227+
let config_path = temp_dir.path().join("config.toml");
228+
229+
// Create test configuration
230+
let config = DeployConfig::test_default();
231+
config.write_to_file(&config_path).await.unwrap();
232+
233+
// Test CLI command
234+
let output = Command::new("torrust-installer")
235+
.args(&["deploy", "--config", config_path.to_str().unwrap(), "--dry-run"])
236+
.output()
237+
.expect("Failed to execute command");
238+
239+
assert!(output.status.success());
240+
assert!(String::from_utf8_lossy(&output.stdout).contains("Deployment plan validated"));
241+
}
242+
243+
#[tokio::test]
244+
async fn test_config_validation() {
245+
let invalid_config = DeployConfig::builder()
246+
.provider("invalid_provider")
247+
.build();
248+
249+
let result = validate_config(&invalid_config).await;
250+
assert!(result.is_err());
251+
assert!(result.unwrap_err().to_string().contains("unsupported provider"));
252+
}
253+
}
254+
```
255+
256+
**Error Handling with anyhow and thiserror**:
257+
258+
```rust
259+
use anyhow::{Context, Result};
260+
use thiserror::Error;
261+
262+
#[derive(Error, Debug)]
263+
pub enum InfrastructureError {
264+
#[error("Configuration validation failed: {message}")]
265+
ConfigValidation { message: String },
266+
267+
#[error("Deployment failed for provider {provider}: {source}")]
268+
DeploymentFailed {
269+
provider: String,
270+
#[source]
271+
source: Box<dyn std::error::Error + Send + Sync>,
272+
},
273+
274+
#[error("Service health check failed after {timeout_seconds}s")]
275+
HealthCheckTimeout { timeout_seconds: u64 },
276+
}
277+
278+
async fn deploy_infrastructure(config: &DeployConfig) -> Result<DeploymentResult> {
279+
validate_prerequisites()
280+
.await
281+
.context("Prerequisites validation failed")?;
282+
283+
let provider = create_provider(&config.provider)
284+
.await
285+
.context("Failed to initialize cloud provider")?;
286+
287+
provider.deploy(config)
288+
.await
289+
.context("Infrastructure deployment failed")?;
290+
291+
wait_for_services(&config.services)
292+
.await
293+
.context("Service startup validation failed")?;
294+
295+
Ok(DeploymentResult::Success)
296+
}
297+
```
298+
299+
**Integration with testcontainers-rs**:
300+
301+
The Rust CLI can integrate seamlessly with container-based testing:
302+
303+
```rust
304+
#[tokio::test]
305+
async fn test_infrastructure_deployment_integration() {
306+
let docker = testcontainers::clients::Cli::default();
307+
308+
// Start test infrastructure
309+
let mysql = docker.run(testcontainers_modules::mysql::Mysql::default());
310+
let nginx = docker.run(testcontainers_modules::nginx::Nginx::default());
311+
312+
// Create test configuration pointing to containers
313+
let config = DeployConfig::builder()
314+
.database_url(format!("mysql://root@localhost:{}/test", mysql.get_host_port_ipv4(3306)))
315+
.proxy_host(format!("localhost:{}", nginx.get_host_port_ipv4(80)))
316+
.build();
317+
318+
// Test deployment against containerized services
319+
let result = deploy_services(&config).await;
320+
assert!(result.is_ok());
321+
322+
// Validate service integration
323+
let health_result = check_service_health(&config).await;
324+
assert!(health_result.is_ok());
325+
}
326+
```

docs/redesign/phase2-analysis/04-testing-strategy.md

Lines changed: 128 additions & 5 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -110,7 +110,7 @@ CI/CD friction:
110110
### Recommended: Container-First Testing Approach
111111

112112
The redesign should prioritize Docker-based testing strategies that eliminate VM dependencies
113-
for most test scenarios:
113+
for most test scenarios, implementing comprehensive infrastructure testing with modern approaches:
114114

115115
**Container Testing Benefits**:
116116

@@ -120,28 +120,151 @@ for most test scenarios:
120120
4. **Reproducibility**: Consistent environment across local and CI systems
121121
5. **Debugging**: Direct access to application logs and state
122122

123+
### Infrastructure Testing-Driven Development (TDD)
124+
125+
Following Test-Driven Development principles for infrastructure provides:
126+
127+
**TDD Infrastructure Benefits**:
128+
129+
- **Early Error Detection**: Catch configuration issues before deployment
130+
- **Regression Prevention**: Automated tests prevent breaking changes
131+
- **Documentation**: Tests serve as living documentation of expected behavior
132+
- **Confidence**: Reliable automated validation enables fearless refactoring
133+
134+
**TDD Implementation Strategy**:
135+
136+
1. **Write Test First**: Define expected infrastructure behavior before implementation
137+
2. **Implement Minimal Code**: Create infrastructure code that makes the test pass
138+
3. **Refactor with Confidence**: Improve code while maintaining test coverage
139+
4. **Continuous Validation**: Run tests on every change to prevent regressions
140+
141+
### Container-Based Testing with testcontainers-rs
142+
143+
The Rust ecosystem provides `testcontainers-rs` for sophisticated container-based testing:
144+
145+
**testcontainers-rs Capabilities**:
146+
147+
- **Multi-Service Orchestration**: Start complex service dependencies in containers
148+
- **Network Isolation**: Each test gets isolated network environments
149+
- **Lifecycle Management**: Automatic container cleanup after test completion
150+
- **Real Service Testing**: Use actual database engines, message queues, web servers
151+
- **Parallel Execution**: Multiple test suites run simultaneously without conflicts
152+
153+
**Infrastructure Testing Architecture**:
154+
155+
```rust
156+
#[cfg(test)]
157+
mod infrastructure_tests {
158+
use testcontainers::*;
159+
use testcontainers_modules::{mysql::Mysql, nginx::Nginx};
160+
161+
#[tokio::test]
162+
async fn test_mysql_tracker_integration() {
163+
let docker = clients::Cli::default();
164+
let mysql_container = docker.run(Mysql::default());
165+
166+
// Test database schema creation
167+
let db_config = create_test_database_config(&mysql_container);
168+
let schema_result = apply_tracker_schema(&db_config).await;
169+
assert!(schema_result.is_ok());
170+
171+
// Test tracker database operations
172+
let tracker = TrackerInstance::new(db_config);
173+
let announce_result = tracker.handle_announce(test_announce()).await;
174+
assert!(announce_result.is_ok());
175+
}
176+
}
177+
```
178+
123179
### Three-Layer Testing Architecture (Enhanced)
124180

125181
#### Layer 1: Unit Tests (Container-Based)
126182

127183
- **Scope**: Individual component testing in isolated containers
128-
- **Tools**: pytest, jest, cargo test, etc.
184+
- **Tools**: pytest, jest, cargo test, testcontainers-rs
129185
- **Execution**: Seconds, runs on every commit
130186
- **Environment**: Docker containers with minimal dependencies
187+
- **TDD Integration**: Write failing tests before implementing features
131188

132189
#### Layer 2: Integration Tests (Container-Based)
133190

134-
- **Scope**: Multi-service testing with Docker Compose
135-
- **Tools**: Docker Compose, Testcontainers, pytest-docker
191+
- **Scope**: Multi-service testing with Docker Compose and testcontainers
192+
- **Tools**: Docker Compose, testcontainers-rs, Rust async testing framework
136193
- **Execution**: 1-3 minutes, runs on every commit
137-
- **Environment**: Full application stack in containers
194+
- **Environment**: Full application stack in containers with realistic data
195+
- **Service Dependencies**: Real MySQL, Redis, Nginx instances in containers
138196

139197
#### Layer 3: E2E Tests (Minimal VM Usage)
140198

141199
- **Scope**: Full deployment validation (reserved for critical scenarios)
142200
- **Tools**: Terraform + cloud providers for real infrastructure testing
143201
- **Execution**: 5-10 minutes, runs on PR merge or nightly
144202
- **Environment**: Actual cloud infrastructure (staging environments)
203+
- **Production Parity**: Test actual deployment procedures and networking
204+
205+
### Multi-Stage Testing Pipeline
206+
207+
**Static Validation (< 1 minute)**:
208+
209+
```bash
210+
# Syntax validation
211+
cargo check --all
212+
terraform validate
213+
yamllint **/*.yml
214+
215+
# Security scanning
216+
cargo audit
217+
terraform plan -detailed-exitcode
218+
```
219+
220+
**Unit Testing (< 2 minutes)**:
221+
222+
```rust
223+
// Infrastructure unit tests
224+
#[tokio::test]
225+
async fn test_tracker_config_generation() {
226+
let config = TrackerConfig::builder()
227+
.database_url("mysql://test:test@localhost/tracker")
228+
.build()
229+
.expect("Valid configuration");
230+
231+
let rendered = config.render_template().await?;
232+
assert!(rendered.contains("mysql://test:test@localhost/tracker"));
233+
}
234+
```
235+
236+
**Container Integration Testing (2-5 minutes)**:
237+
238+
```rust
239+
#[tokio::test]
240+
async fn test_full_tracker_stack() {
241+
let docker = clients::Cli::default();
242+
243+
// Start dependencies
244+
let mysql = docker.run(Mysql::default());
245+
let nginx = docker.run(Nginx::default());
246+
247+
// Test complete tracker deployment
248+
let stack = TrackerStack::new()
249+
.with_database(&mysql)
250+
.with_proxy(&nginx)
251+
.deploy().await?;
252+
253+
// Verify service health
254+
assert!(stack.health_check().await.is_ok());
255+
256+
// Test tracker protocol
257+
let announce = stack.udp_announce(test_torrent_hash()).await?;
258+
assert_eq!(announce.peers.len(), 0); // Empty tracker
259+
}
260+
```
261+
262+
**E2E Testing (5-10 minutes)**:
263+
264+
- Cloud provider integration tests
265+
- Network security validation
266+
- Performance benchmarking
267+
- Multi-region deployment testing
145268

146269
### Implementation Strategy
147270

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)