Skip to content

chore(hq-em): EM cycle 2026-03-31T04:48Z — 9 PRs merged, 5 Preflight issues triaged, analytics version correction #1498

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Merged
jpleva91 merged 1 commit into from
Mar 31, 2026
Merged

chore(hq-em): EM cycle 2026-03-31T04:48Z — 9 PRs merged, 5 Preflight issues triaged, analytics version correction #1498

Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
1 commit
Select commit
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
304 changes: 76 additions & 228 deletions .agentguard/squads/hq/em-report.json
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,297 +1,145 @@
{
"squad": "hq",
"generatedAt": "2026-03-30T21:00:00.000Z",
"identity": "claude-code:opus:hq:em",
"generatedAt": "2026-03-31T04:48:00.000Z",
"identity": "claude-code:unknown:planner (hq:em)",
"runCycle": "3h",
"health": "red",
"healthReason": "Three P0 blockers persist: worker pool dead (#1402, cycle 11), codex budget exhausted (#1431, cycle 6, auto-resolves Apr 3), swarm health crisis (#1452, cycle 2). New: governance report #1462 reveals 99.9% sessions lack agent identity and team compliance metric broken. Cloud version drift enters 9th cycle (2.10.1 vs 2.10.3).",
"summary": "Active cycle. Closed stale conflicting PR #1461 (18:00Z, superseded). PR #1455 (marketing-em) still CONFLICTING — 2nd rebase request. New governance report #1462 filed by governance-monitor-agent reveals 5 HIGH-priority systemic issues: agent identity 99.9% missing, `gh` CLI false positive, team compliance metric broken, `no-secret-exposure` sev5 dormancy suspicious, `no-governance-self-modification` firing 2,073 times at monitor mode. Sprint goal on track: Go kernel→Cloud telemetry E2E pipeline (due Apr 17). KE-2 shipped, KE-8 complete. Circuit breakers auto-resolve Apr 1 (2 days).",
"healthReason": "Three P0 blockers persist: worker pool dead (#1402, cycle 12), codex budget exhausted (#1431, cycle 7 — auto-resolves 2026-04-03), swarm health crisis (#1452, cycle 3). Version drift: agentguard-cloud 2.10.1 (10th cycle, P0); agentguard-analytics version discrepancy discovered — actual version is 2.7.3 (3+ minor versions behind, previous reports were WRONG, P1). Governance systemic issues from #1462 remain unresolved by kernel-squad/hq-ops (cycle 2).",
"summary": "Productive cycle. Merged 9 PRs: kernel-em #1497, dependabot #1484–#1491 (actions/checkout v6, deploy-pages v5, codeql-action, setup-go v6, re2js, typescript-eslint, turbo, MCP SDK). Closed stale marketing-em PR #1455 after 3 CONFLICTING cycles. Triaged 5 new Preflight protocol issues (#1492–#1496, kernel squad, P2–P3). CORRECTION: agentguard-analytics is on 2.7.3 not 2.10.2 — previous EM reports were reading wrong source. Circuit breakers (#1335) auto-closed. Security alerts (#1449) resolved by PR #1469. Sprint goal on track: Go kernel→Cloud E2E (due Apr 17). KE-2 shipped, KE-8 complete, KE-9 assigned (PR #1497 merged).",
"sprintStatus": {
"goal": "Validate Go kernel→Cloud telemetry E2E pipeline (workspace #60, due Apr 17). KE-2 SHIPPED. KE-8 COMPLETE. Version sync. ShellForge coordination.",
"issues": [
1402,
1403,
1431,
1449,
1452,
1462
],
"resolvedThisSprint": [
1427,
1430
],
"goal": "Validate Go kernel→Cloud telemetry E2E pipeline (workspace #60, due Apr 17). KE-2 SHIPPED. KE-8 COMPLETE. KE-9 IN PROGRESS.",
"issues": [1402, 1403, 1431, 1452, 1462],
"resolvedThisSprint": [1427, 1430, 1335, 1449],
"nearResolution": [
{
"issue": 1335,
"note": "Codex + Copilot circuit breakers auto-resolve 2026-04-01 (2 days)"
"issue": 1431,
"note": "Codex budget auto-resolves 2026-04-03 (3 days)"
},
{
"issue": 1431,
"note": "Codex budget auto-resolves 2026-04-03 (4 days)"
"issue": 1402,
"note": "Worker pool blocked on human action (jpleva91 must run server/deploy.sh). Cycle 12."
}
]
},
"ciStatus": {
"agentGuard": "green",
"agentguardCloud": "green (CI passes; systemic exit=1 agent failures are runtime/policy, not CI)",
"agentguardCloud": "green (CI passes; systemic exit=1 agent failures are runtime/policy mismatch with version 2.10.1)",
"agentguardAnalytics": "unknown",
"recentRuns": "agent-guard main: 4 CI green runs (latest 84050d5 kernel-qa). agentguard-cloud: 5 recent runs all green.",
"recentMerges": "PR #1497 (kernel-em KE-9), #1484 (checkout v6), #1485 (deploy-pages v5), #1486 (codeql-action), #1487 (setup-go v6), #1488 (re2js), #1489 (typescript-eslint), #1490 (turbo), #1491 (MCP SDK). All merged this cycle.",
"securityAlerts": {
"count": 3,
"breakdown": "1 high (path-to-regexp ReDoS), 2 moderate (path-to-regexp DoS, brace-expansion hang)",
"status": "Issue #1449 open — pending director triage and patch assignment"
"count": 0,
"status": "RESOLVED — PR #1469 patched path-to-regexp and brace-expansion (#1449 closed)."
}
},
"versionMatrix": {
"latest": "2.10.3",
"agentGuard": "2.10.3",
"agentguardCloud": "2.10.1",
"agentguardAnalytics": "2.10.2",
"agentguardAnalytics": "2.7.3",
"drift": {
"agentguardCloud": "2 patches behind (P0 — 9th consecutive cycle, CRITICAL. Cloud systemic failures likely related.)",
"agentguardAnalytics": "1 patch behind (P2)"
"agentguardCloud": "2 patches behind (P0 — 10th consecutive cycle, CRITICAL. Cloud systemic failures are likely caused by policy/config mismatch with older version.)",
"agentguardAnalytics": "3+ minor versions behind (P1 — CORRECTION: previous EM reports incorrectly stated 2.10.2. Actual root package.json shows 2.7.3. Requires urgent upgrade investigation.)"
}
},
"prQueue": {
"agentGuard": {
"open": 1,
"open": 0,
"mergedThisCycle": [1497, 1484, 1485, 1486, 1487, 1488, 1489, 1490, 1491],
"closedThisCycle": [
{
"number": 1461,
"title": "chore(hq-em): EM cycle 2026-03-30T18:00Z",
"reason": "CONFLICTING, superseded by this cycle (21:00Z)"
}
],
"awaitingRebase": [
{
"number": 1455,
"title": "chore(marketing-em): EM cycle 2026-03-30T20:00Z",
"status": "CONFLICTING — 2nd rebase request this run"
"reason": "CONFLICTING for 3 consecutive EM cycles — no rebase activity. Closed with comment requesting fresh PR."
}
]
}
},
"dogfoodPatterns": [
{
"pattern": "Hook stderr false-blocks allowed decisions on Bash tool",
"issues": [1430],
"severity": "P1",
"status": "RESOLVED",
"resolvedBy": "PR #1448 merged 2026-03-30T12:10Z — fix(claude-hook): allow-path must not write to stderr. KE-8 COMPLETE."
},
{
"pattern": "Automated agents can self-modify .agentguard/persona.env",
"issues": [1427],
"severity": "P1",
"status": "RESOLVED",
"resolvedBy": "PR #1436 — no-governance-self-modification invariant now blocks writes to persona.env."
},
{
"pattern": "`gh` CLI commands false-positive in destructive command scanner",
"issues": [1462],
"severity": "P1",
"status": "NEW",
"description": "From governance report #1462: `gh issue create` and similar `gh` CLI commands are being flagged by the destructive command scanner due to heredoc body content matching destructive patterns. Causes unnecessary denials for governance agent PR/issue creation.",
"recommendation": "Kernel squad: add `gh` CLI allowlist to command scanner, or scope destructive pattern detection to bare shell commands only."
},
{
"pattern": "99.9% of sessions lack agent identity (AGENTGUARD_AGENT_NAME not set)",
"issues": [1462],
"severity": "P1",
"status": "NEW",
"description": "Governance report #1462: 65,830 sessions analyzed, near-zero have agent identity set. scripts/write-persona.sh does not export AGENTGUARD_AGENT_NAME to environment. Agent schedule configs also missing identity.",
"recommendation": "HQ: add AGENTGUARD_AGENT_NAME export to write-persona.sh output and all agent schedule entries. New issue required."
},
"newIssuesTriaged": [
{
"pattern": "Session-to-agent attribution join broken — team compliance metric shows 0/0",
"issues": [1462],
"severity": "P1",
"status": "NEW",
"description": "All named agents report 0/0 allowed/denied in team compliance metrics. Storage layer join broken.",
"recommendation": "Kernel/storage squad: investigate attribution join. New issue required."
"number": 1492,
"title": "[kernel] MCP server enforcement layer for Preflight protocol",
"priority": "P3 / priority:low",
"squad": "kernel",
"note": "Post-v1 nice-to-have. Gate on Preflight v1 adoption."
},
{
"pattern": "no-secret-exposure (sev5) dormant across 65,830 sessions — suspicious",
"issues": [1462],
"severity": "P2",
"status": "NEW",
"description": "With an active .env-write deny rule and 65,830 sessions, the no-secret-exposure severity-5 invariant triggering zero times is anomalous. Possible wiring bug.",
"recommendation": "Kernel squad: verify no-secret-exposure is correctly wired for file.write against .env patterns. New issue required."
"number": 1493,
"title": "[kernel] Integrate Preflight protocol into AgentGuard governance hooks",
"priority": "P2 / priority:medium",
"squad": "kernel",
"note": "Key integration bridge between Preflight protocol and AgentGuard mechanical enforcement. Depends on Preflight v1 shipping."
},
{
"pattern": "Cloud squad systemic exit=1 failures (74.3%) beyond codex budget",
"issues": [1452],
"severity": "P1",
"status": "ONGOING",
"description": "cloud-sr (96.2%), ci-triage-agent-cloud (86.7%), coder-agent-cloud (78.3%), cloud-em (73.7%) failing at exit=1. Version drift (2.10.1 vs 2.10.3) likely contributing.",
"recommendation": "Cloud-squad: upgrade to 2.10.3 immediately (9th cycle). Director: investigate policy/config root cause."
"number": 1494,
"title": "[kernel] Preflight Protocol JSON schema for machine-readable validation",
"priority": "P3 / priority:low",
"squad": "kernel",
"note": "Belongs primarily in the preflight repo. Needs refinement for scope."
},
{
"pattern": "Orphaned vitest processes from deleted worktrees consuming RAM",
"issues": [1452],
"severity": "P2",
"status": "ONGOING",
"description": "26 vitest worker processes (~3.3GB RAM). Human kill command provided. Kernel squad: fix worktree cleanup to force-kill children.",
"recommendation": "Human: kill zombie processes (commands in humanActionsRequired). Kernel squad: implement child-process cleanup on worktree removal."
"number": 1495,
"title": "[kernel] State Witness — re-validate conditions at execution time",
"priority": "P2 / priority:medium",
"squad": "kernel",
"note": "Addresses TOCTOU gap in propose→execute lifecycle. Important correctness/security concern."
},
{
"pattern": "dogfood-reporting.md missing",
"severity": "P3",
"status": "KNOWN",
"recommendation": "Create claude/shared/dogfood-reporting.md."
"number": 1496,
"title": "[kernel] Risk-gated write lifecycle — draft/review/execute for tool calls",
"priority": "P2 / priority:medium",
"squad": "kernel",
"note": "Architecturally significant: 3-stage lifecycle replaces binary risk threshold. KE-9 or KE-10 candidate."
}
],
"crossCuttingIssues": [
"blockers": [
{
"issue": 1402,
"title": "[P0] Worker pool dead — 11th cycle, swarm frozen",
"severity": "P0",
"cycleCount": 11,
"description": "All PIDs dead. 26 orphaned vitest processes also consuming ~3.3GB RAM. Every squad's scheduled agents blocked.",
"action": "HUMAN REQUIRED: cd ~/agentguard-workspace && server/deploy.sh; kill zombie vitests; git worktree prune"
"description": "P0: Worker pool dead on jared box. 12+ cycles, swarm frozen. Human must run server/deploy.sh.",
"escalatedTo": "human (jpleva91)",
"escalationCount": 12
},
{
"issue": 1431,
"title": "[P0] Codex budget exhausted — cycle 6",
"severity": "P0",
"cycleCount": 6,
"description": "25+ codex-driver agents offline. Auto-resolves 2026-04-03T02:25Z (4 days). Director decision still pending.",
"action": "Director: decide credits purchase OR disable codex agents in schedule.json until 2026-04-03."
"description": "P0: Codex budget exhausted until Apr 3. 25+ agents offline. Auto-resolves 2026-04-03T02:25Z.",
"escalatedTo": "human + director",
"escalationCount": 7
},
{
"issue": 1452,
"title": "[P0] 69.5% swarm failure + 26 zombie vitest + cloud systemic failures — cycle 2",
"severity": "P0",
"cycleCount": 2,
"description": "Human must kill zombie processes + prune stuck worktrees. Cloud squad systemic exit=1 failures ongoing.",
"action": "Human: kill zombie processes + prune stuck worktrees. Cloud-squad: upgrade to 2.10.3. Director: investigate cloud policy."
"description": "P0 (cycle 3): 69.5% agent failure rate, 26 orphaned vitest processes (~3.3GB RAM), cloud-squad 74.3% exit=1. Human must kill zombies + prune worktrees. Cloud-squad must upgrade to 2.10.3.",
"escalatedTo": "human (zombie kill + worktree prune) + director (cloud systemic) + cloud-squad (upgrade)",
"escalationCount": 3
},
{
"issue": 1462,
"title": "[NEW] Governance & Policy Report — 5 HIGH-priority systemic issues",
"severity": "P1",
"description": "65,830 sessions analyzed. Key findings: 99.9% missing agent identity, gh CLI false positive, team compliance metric broken, no-secret-exposure dormancy, policy gaps (git.reset/npm.publish/github.pr.approve).",
"action": "HQ: file issues for agent identity enforcement and gh CLI false positive. Kernel squad: investigate no-secret-exposure and attribution join. Policy gaps assigned to kernel-squad."
"description": "P1 (cycle 2): Governance report — 5 HIGH systemic issues: agent identity 99.9% missing, gh CLI false positive, team compliance broken, no-secret-exposure dormant, policy gaps. Kernel-squad and hq-ops have assignments.",
"escalatedTo": "kernel-squad + hq-ops",
"escalationCount": 2
},
{
"issue": 1403,
"title": "[P1] readybench QA swarm non-operational — 5+ days",
"severity": "P1",
"description": "All 19 readybench agents skipping. Depends on #1402.",
"action": "Ops: fix routing after #1402 resolved."
},
{
"issue": 1335,
"title": "Codex + Copilot circuit breakers OPEN — auto-resolves Apr 1",
"severity": "P1",
"action": "Wait. 2 days."
},
{
"title": "Version drift: cloud 2.10.1 vs 2.10.3 (9th cycle — P0 CRITICAL)",
"severity": "P0",
"description": "Cloud 2 patches behind. 9th consecutive cycle. Likely contributing to systemic exit=1 failures.",
"action": "Cloud squad: upgrade to 2.10.3 NOW."
},
{
"issue": 1177,
"title": "pr-merger-agent policy gap — github.pr.* not in default allow-list",
"severity": "P2",
"description": "234 lifetime failures.",
"action": "Kernel squad: add github.pr.* to default allow-list."
},
{
"issue": 1449,
"title": "Dependabot security alerts — 3 open",
"severity": "P2",
"action": "Director: assign patch work. 1 high severity (path-to-regexp ReDoS)."
},
{
"title": "ShellForge initiative (#1362-#1367) — 8th cycle unassigned",
"severity": "P2",
"action": "Director: assign ShellForge squad owner."
}
],
"resolvedSinceLastCycle": [
{
"pr": 1461,
"title": "Stale HQ EM 18:00Z PR closed (CONFLICTING, superseded)",
"action": "CLOSED by HQ EM 21:00Z cycle"
"description": "P1: readybench QA swarm non-operational 5+ days. Depends on #1402.",
"escalatedTo": "ops",
"firstSeen": "2026-03-25T00:00:00.000Z"
}
],
"escalations": [
{
"priority": "P0",
"target": "human (jpleva91)",
"cycleCount": 11,
"reason": "#1402: Worker pool dead. Kill 26 zombie vitest processes, prune 3 stuck worktrees, run server/deploy.sh."
},
{
"priority": "P0",
"target": "director",
"cycleCount": 6,
"reason": "#1431: codex budget exhausted until Apr 3. Decision required. Auto-resolves in 4 days."
},
{
"priority": "P0",
"target": "director + cloud-squad",
"cycleCount": 2,
"reason": "#1452 + version drift: Cloud squad 74.3% exit=1 (9th cycle 2.10.1 vs 2.10.3). Upgrade immediately."
},
{
"priority": "P1",
"target": "kernel-squad",
"cycleCount": 1,
"reason": "#1462: File issues for gh CLI false positive (#1462-a), no-secret-exposure dormancy (#1462-b), attribution join broken (#1462-c). Policy gaps: add git.reset/npm.publish explicit rules."
},
{
"priority": "P1",
"target": "hq-ops",
"cycleCount": 1,
"reason": "#1462: Add AGENTGUARD_AGENT_NAME export to write-persona.sh and all agent schedule entries. 99.9% sessions lack identity."
},
{
"priority": "P2",
"target": "director",
"cycleCount": 8,
"reason": "ShellForge squad owner needed. #1449 dependabot triage (1 high). #1177 pr-merger-agent gap (234 failures)."
"crossRepoCoordination": {
"versionSync": {
"agentguardCloud": "BLOCKED — 10th cycle. Cloud-squad must upgrade agentguard.yaml + package.json to 2.10.3. This is almost certainly causing the 74.3% exit=1 systemic failures.",
"agentguardAnalytics": "CORRECTION: actual version is 2.7.3 (root package.json). Previous EM reports incorrectly showed 2.10.2. Director should prioritize analytics upgrade plan."
}
],
"humanActionsRequired": [
"cd ~/agentguard-workspace && server/deploy.sh # restart worker pool (#1402) — cycle 11",
"ps aux | grep 'cloud-qa-257589\\|cloud-sr-1428111\\|tier-c-copilot-implementer-1127453' | grep vitest | awk '{print $2}' | xargs kill # kill 26 zombie vitest (~3.3GB RAM)",
"cd ~/agentguard-workspace/agent-guard && git worktree prune",
"rm -rf /home/jared/agentguard-workspace/.worktrees/marketing-em-3815251 /home/jared/agentguard-workspace/.worktrees/octi-pulpo-sr-3847600 /home/jared/agentguard-workspace/.worktrees/octi-pulpo-qa-3847601",
"Decision: purchase codex credits OR edit server/schedule.json to disable codex agents until 2026-04-03"
],
"actionsThisCycle": [
{
"action": "CLOSED_PR",
"pr": 1461,
"detail": "18:00Z HQ EM cycle — CONFLICTING, superseded by 21:00Z cycle. Closed to keep PR queue clean."
},
{
"action": "PR_STATUS",
"pr": 1455,
"detail": "marketing-em still CONFLICTING. 2nd rebase request pending."
},
{
"action": "TRIAGE_ISSUE",
"issue": 1462,
"detail": "Governance & Policy Report analyzed. 5 HIGH items surfaced: agent identity, gh CLI false positive, compliance metric, no-secret-exposure dormancy, policy gaps. Escalated to kernel-squad and hq-ops."
},
{
"action": "VERSION_CHECK",
"detail": "agentguard-cloud confirmed 2.10.1 (package.json). agentguard-analytics confirmed 2.10.2. agent-guard CLI 2.10.3. Cloud drift enters 9th cycle."
},
},
"dogfoodPatterns": [
{
"action": "ESCALATED_COUNT",
"issue": 1402,
"detail": "Cycle 11 escalation."
"pattern": "No governance denials encountered during this EM session (persona write, PR merges, issue edits all passed through).",
"severity": "info",
"status": "nominal"
},
{
"action": "ESCALATED_COUNT",
"issue": 1431,
"detail": "Cycle 6 escalation. Auto-resolves Apr 3."
"pattern": "Identity set as claude-code:unknown:planner — note 'unknown' model field from write-persona.sh. Relates to #1462 agent identity gap (hq-ops task).",
"severity": "warning",
"status": "open",
"relatedIssue": 1462
}
]
}
Loading
Loading