Proposals 9202-9309

src/main/kotlin/org/agoranomic/assessor/decisions/9302-9309.kt

@@ -0,0 +1,353 @@
+package org.agoranomic.assessor.decisions
+
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.assessment
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.receivers.ai
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.receivers.quorum
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.receivers.url
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.votes.complexityBonuses
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.votes.endorse
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.votes.onOrdinaryProposals
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.dsl.votes.resolvedConditional
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.lib.vote.ResolvedVote
+import org.agoranomic.assessor.lib.vote.VoteKind.*
+
+@UseAssessment
+fun assessment9302to9309() = assessment {
+    name("9302-9309")
+    url("https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2026-March/019066.html")
+    quorum(5)
+
+    strengths {
+        default(3)
+        min(0)
+        max(15)
+
+        onOrdinaryProposals {
+            complexityBonuses {
+                maxBonus(3)
+
+                "Absurdor"(1) heldBy juan
+                "ADoP"(2) heldBy Murphy
+                "Arbitor"(2) heldBy null
+                "Archivist"(1) heldBy kiako
+                "Assessor"(3) heldBy Janet
+                "Collar"(1) heldBy Mischief
+                "Collector"(2) heldBy Mischief
+                "Distributor"(0) heldBy omd
+                "Herald"(2) heldBy snail
+                "Illuminator"(1) heldBy Cosmo
+                "Land Managor"(1) heldBy Murphy
+                "Notary"(2) heldBy null
+                "Numerator"(1) heldBy Trigon
+                "Prime Minister"(0) heldBy null
+                "Promotor"(3) heldBy Cosmo
+                "Referee"(2) heldBy ais523
+                "Registrar"(1) heldBy juan
+                "Rulekeepor"(3) heldBy Janet
+                "Speaker"(0) heldBy kiako
+                "Spendor"(1) heldBy Murphy
+                "Tailor"(1) heldBy Murphy
+                "Webmastor"(1) heldBy kiako
+            }
+        }
+    }
+
+    proposals(v4) {
+        proposal(9302) {
+            title("No Lingering Instruments")
+            ai("3.0")
+            author(Mischief)
+            democratic()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend rule 106 (Adopting Proposals) by replacing the text reading "Once
+a proposal finishes taking effect, its power is set to 0." with "If, at
+any time, a proposal has finished taking effect, its power is set to 0."
+
+[To see the difference, consider a proposal that took effect before the
+to-be-replaced language was in place.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9303) {
+            title("Voluntary Turnover")
+            ai("2.0")
+            author(Mischief)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend rule 1006 (Offices) by replacing the text reading:
+
+       The non-interim holder of an elected office CAN, with 3 support,
+       resign the office while appointing another player to become the
+       holder of the office, provided that other player is one of the
+       supporters.
+
+with:
+
+       The non-interim holder of a voluntary office CAN, with 3 support,
+       resign the office while appointing another player to become the
+       holder of the office, provided that other player is one of the
+       supporters.
+
+[Expand the option to sortitioned offices too.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9304) {
+            title("Fix Welcome Packages")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Mischief)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend rule 2499 (Welcome Packages) to read:
+
+       A player CAN, by announcement, cause a specified player to receive
+       a welcome package (syn. "grant" em a welcome package).
+
+       When a player receives a welcome package, if e has not received a
+       welcome package, including under any previous definition, since e
+       last registered nor in the past 30 days, then e:
+
+       * gains 15 spendies, if e has not been granted any spendies since
+         e last registered;
+       * gains 16 Hectares; and
+       * scores the date of eir registration.
+
+[Let's stop the bleeding, at least. How to clean it up equitably is a
+much thornier issue.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9305) {
+            title("Fix temporary deputisation ISIDTID")
+            ai("3.0")
+            author(ais523)
+            democratic()
+
+            text(
+                """
+In rule 2160, change
+{{{
+3) The deputy, when performing the action, announces that e is
+    doing so by deputisation or by temporary deputisation.
+}}}
+to
+{{{
+3) The deputy, when performing the action, announces that e is
+    doing so by deputisation or by temporary deputisation (in the
+    latter case, the deputisation is considered temporary).
+}}}
+
+[The rule allowed you to announce that you were performing temporary
+deputisation but didn't specify any consequences for doing so, meaning
+that AFAICT an announcement of temporary deputisation would actually
+deputise permanently.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9306) {
+            title("Ratification timing clarification")
+            ai("3.2")
+            author(ais523)
+            democratic()
+
+            text(
+                """
+In rule 1551, change
+{{{
+the gamestate is modified to what it would be if
+}}}
+to
+{{{
+the gamestate is modified to what it would currently be if
+}}}
+
+[A possible reading of rule 1551 is that ratification rewinds the
+entire gamestate to the truth time. I think (or at least hope) that
+reading loses the rule 217 tiebreak, but given how important
+ratification is to keeping Agora working, and how problematic it would
+be to have the gamestate randomly rewind, I would like to make this
+unambiguous.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9307) {
+            title("Cleaner punctuation")
+            ai("3.0")
+            author(ais523)
+            democratic()
+
+            text(
+                """
+In rule 2221, change "spelling, grammar," to "spelling, grammar,
+punctuation,".
+
+In rule 107, if the penultimate paragraph does not end with a full
+stop, append a full stop to it.
+
+In rule 2555, in "A person with 1 or more blots is Impure, a
+person with 0 blots is Pure.", change the comma to a semicolon.
+
+In rule 2555, if the second paragraph does not end with a full stop,
+append a full stop to it.
+
+[Allow cleaning for punctuation, which currently isn't possible. Also
+contains some fixes for punctuation errors I noticed.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9308) {
+            title("Fix passive SHOULD")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(ais523)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+In rule 2492, change
+{{{
+If a judge is recused from a case that was continuously open and
+assigned to em for at least the past 4 days, e SHOULD NOT be
+assigned as a judge until e has apologised and/or reasonably
+explained eir actions.
+}}}
+to
+{{{
+If a judge is recused from a case that was continuously open and
+assigned to em for at least the past 4 days, players SHOULD NOT
+assign em as a judge until e has apologised and/or reasonably
+explained eir actions.
+}}}
+
+[With the current wording, if the Arbitor assigns a judge too early, it
+is the judge rather than the Arbitor who has violated the SHOULD, which
+is not what we want. "Players" rather than "the Arbitor" because there
+are some situations where players other than the Arbitor do the
+assignment, e.g. if the Referee is handling a CFJ.]"""
+            )
+        }
+
+        proposal(9309) {
+            title("Packing list")
+            ai("1.0")
+            author(Murphy)
+            ordinary()
+
+            text(
+                """
+Amend Rule 2499 (Welcome Packages) by replacing this text:
+
+       A player CAN, by announcement, cause a specified player to receive
+       a welcome package (syn. "grant" em a welcome package).
+
+with this text:
+
+       A player CAN, by announcement, cause a specified player to receive
+       a welcome package (syn. "grant" em a welcome package), and SHOULD
+       specify the assets thus gained."""
+            )
+        }
+    }
+
+    voting {
+        votes(Cosmo) {
+            FOR on 9302
+            PRESENT on 9303
+            FOR on 9304
+            PRESENT on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            FOR on 9308
+            FOR on 9309
+        }
+
+        votes(juan) {
+            FOR on 9302
+            PRESENT on 9303
+            PRESENT on 9304
+            PRESENT on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            PRESENT on 9308
+            PRESENT on 9309
+        }
+
+        votes(Trigon) {
+            PRESENT on 9302
+            FOR on 9303
+            FOR on 9304
+            FOR on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            FOR on 9308
+            FOR on 9309
+        }
+
+        votes(Mischief) {
+            FOR on 9302
+            FOR on 9303
+            FOR on 9304
+            FOR on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            FOR on 9308
+            FOR on 9309
+        }
+
+        votes(Nilrem) {
+            PRESENT on 9302
+            FOR on 9303
+            FOR on 9304
+            PRESENT on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            FOR on 9308
+            FOR on 9309
+        }
+
+        votes(Janet) {
+            function { ctx ->
+                if (ctx.resolve(ctx.currentProposal, ais523) != null) {
+                    resolvedConditional(endorse(ais523), "ais523 voted")
+                } else {
+                    ResolvedVote(FOR)
+                }
+            } on 9302
+
+            AGAINST on 9303
+            FOR on 9304
+            FOR on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            FOR on 9308
+            AGAINST on 9309
+        }
+
+        votes(ais523) {
+            FOR on 9302
+            PRESENT on 9303
+            FOR on 9304
+            FOR on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            FOR on 9308
+            AGAINST on 9309
+        }
+
+        votes(Murphy) {
+            FOR on 9302
+            FOR on 9303
+            FOR on 9304
+            FOR on 9305
+            FOR on 9306
+            FOR on 9307
+            FOR on 9308
+            FOR on 9309
+        }
+    }
+}