Conversation
athena-omt
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
No blocking findings in the visible diff. The new std/outcome.ax helpers are scoped to pure Axiom match wrappers over the existing Option<T> and Result<T, E> forms, and the example/docs cover the intended bounded helper surface without adding host runtime or panic behavior.
I am leaving this as a comment rather than approval because the PR is currently reported dirty / non-mergeable, so the final merged diff still needs to be re-established against main. I also could not run local read-only checks from the required worktree because the command sandbox failed before starting commands with bwrap: Failed to make / slave: Permission denied.
Suggested non-blocking follow-up: after rebasing/merging main, consider extending stdlib_outcome to print the false predicate branches too (option_is_some(None), option_is_none(Some), result_is_ok(Err), result_is_err(Ok)) so every helper branch is represented explicitly.
pheidon
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pheidon sweep review: approved. I inspected the Option/Result outcome helper stdlib additions and example. The helpers are added to the synthetic stdlib surface with docs and a deterministic stdlib_outcome example covering is_some/is_none/is_ok/is_err-style usage. Validation: git diff --check origin/main...HEAD; cargo run --manifest-path stage1/Cargo.toml -p axiomc -- test stage1/examples/stdlib_outcome --json. No blocker found.
Summary
std/outcome.axwith genericOption<T>andResult<T, E>helper predicates.stage1/examples/stdlib_outcomeand docs for the bounded helper surface.Governing Issue
Closes #407
Validation
cargo run --manifest-path stage1/Cargo.toml -p axiomc -- test stage1/examples/stdlib_outcome --jsoncargo fmt --manifest-path stage1/Cargo.tomlgit diff --checkCI GateBootstrap Governance
Notes