-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 0
feat: Add string manipulation utilities #14
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
base: main
Are you sure you want to change the base?
Conversation
- Added case conversion functions (snake, camel, pascal, kebab) - Added text truncation with custom suffix - Added word counting utility - Comprehensive test coverage (69 tests) - Handles edge cases like consecutive capitals (XMLHttpRequest)
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Pull Request Overview
This PR adds a comprehensive string manipulation utilities module with case conversion functions and text processing utilities. The implementation includes proper handling of edge cases like consecutive capitals, numbers, and special characters.
- Added 6 utility functions for common string transformations (snake, camel, pascal, kebab case conversions, text truncation, and word counting)
- Implemented robust edge case handling for empty strings, special characters, and various delimiter styles
- Added comprehensive test coverage with 69 unit tests covering all functions and edge cases
Reviewed Changes
Copilot reviewed 2 out of 2 changed files in this pull request and generated 1 comment.
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| src/string_utils.py | Main implementation of string utility functions with proper documentation and type hints |
| tests/test_string_utils.py | Comprehensive test suite with parameterized tests covering normal cases and edge scenarios |
Tip: Customize your code reviews with copilot-instructions.md. Create the file or learn how to get started.
PR Reviewer Guide 🔍Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
🤖 AI Code Review
Code Review for PR #14
Overall Assessment:
The implementation of string manipulation utilities is well-structured and includes comprehensive test coverage. The code is generally clean and follows Python conventions. However, there are a few areas where improvements can be made, particularly regarding edge cases, performance, and documentation.
Issues Identified:
-
Edge Case Handling in
to_kebab_caseandto_snake_case:- Issue: The current implementation does not handle cases where there are consecutive capital letters or multiple delimiters effectively. For instance,
to_kebab_case("XMLHttpRequest")should returnxml-http-request, but it currently returnsxml-http-requestcorrectly. - Solution: You can enhance the regex patterns to handle consecutive capital letters more robustly. For example, you might want to add a check for sequences of uppercase letters followed by lowercase letters.
text = re.sub(r'([A-Z]+)([A-Z][a-z])', r'\1-\2', text) # Existing line text = re.sub(r'([a-z0-9])([A-Z])', r'\1-\2', text) # Existing line
- Issue: The current implementation does not handle cases where there are consecutive capital letters or multiple delimiters effectively. For instance,
-
Performance Considerations:
- Issue: The regex operations in the conversion functions can be optimized. Each function currently uses multiple regex substitutions, which may lead to performance issues for larger strings.
- Solution: Consider combining some of the regex patterns into a single pass where possible, or use string manipulation methods that may be faster.
-
Documentation Improvements:
- Issue: While the docstrings are generally clear, they could benefit from mentioning the expected behavior for edge cases directly in the examples.
- Solution: Add examples in the docstrings that demonstrate how the functions handle edge cases, such as consecutive delimiters or special characters.
-
Test Coverage:
- Issue: The test cases are comprehensive, but there are some edge cases that could be added for better coverage, such as:
- Strings with only special characters.
- Very long strings to test performance.
- Solution: Consider adding more test cases in
TestEdgeCasesto cover these scenarios.
- Issue: The test cases are comprehensive, but there are some edge cases that could be added for better coverage, such as:
-
Return Type Consistency:
- Issue: In
truncate_text, ifmax_lengthis less than or equal to the length ofsuffix, it returns a substring ofsuffix, which may not be intuitive. - Solution: You might want to return an empty string or a specific message indicating that truncation is not possible.
if max_length <= len(suffix): return "" # or handle it in a way that fits your use case
- Issue: In
-
Unused Imports:
- Issue: The import statement for
Listfromtypingis not used in the code. - Solution: Remove the unused import to keep the code clean.
- Issue: The import statement for
Conclusion:
The implementation is solid and covers a wide range of string manipulation needs. However, addressing the issues mentioned above will improve the robustness, performance, and clarity of the code.
Recommendation:
REQUEST_CHANGES
Please address the issues outlined above, particularly focusing on edge case handling, performance optimizations, and enhancing documentation.
Automated review by Synvara AI
📊 Review Details
- Review type: REQUEST_CHANGES
- Strategy: initial
- Files reviewed: 2
- Changes: +350 -0
- Commit: 5ab168e
- Timestamp: 2025-08-28T16:35:48.596Z
PR Code Suggestions ✨Explore these optional code suggestions:
|
||||||||||||
Improvements made: 1. Performance Optimizations: - Precompiled regex patterns for better performance - Single-pass regex operations where possible - Performance tests confirm <10ms for long strings 2. Edge Case Handling: - Improved handling of consecutive delimiters - Better handling of special characters - Proper cleanup of leading/trailing delimiters 3. Documentation Enhancements: - Added edge case examples in docstrings - Clear behavior documentation for all functions - Unicode handling notes 4. New Features: - Added is_mixed_case() function - Added remove_extra_whitespace() utility 5. Test Coverage: - Expanded to 103 tests (from 69) - Added performance benchmarks - Added special character tests - Unicode handling tests 6. Code Quality: - Removed unused imports - Improved truncate_text return behavior - All functions handle empty strings gracefully
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
🔄 AI Code Re-Review
Code Review for PR #14 (Follow-Up Review)
Overall Assessment:
The recent changes made to the string manipulation utilities have addressed most of the previous concerns raised in the initial review. The implementation now includes improved edge case handling, performance optimizations, and enhanced documentation. However, there are still a couple of areas that require attention.
Review of Previous Concerns:
-
Edge Case Handling in
to_kebab_caseandto_snake_case:- Previous Concern: The handling of consecutive capital letters and multiple delimiters was not robust.
- Current Status: The regex patterns have been improved to handle consecutive capitals and delimiters effectively. This is now correctly implemented.
-
Performance Considerations:
- Previous Concern: The regex operations were potentially inefficient.
- Current Status: The regex patterns have been precompiled and optimized for performance. This is a significant improvement.
-
Documentation Improvements:
- Previous Concern: Docstrings needed examples for edge cases.
- Current Status: The docstrings have been enhanced with examples that cover edge cases, making the expected behavior clearer.
-
Test Coverage:
- Previous Concern: Additional edge cases were needed in tests.
- Current Status: The test suite has been expanded significantly, now covering various edge cases, including special characters and performance benchmarks.
-
Return Type Consistency in
truncate_text:- Previous Concern: The return behavior when
max_lengthis less than or equal to the length ofsuffixwas not intuitive. - Current Status: The function now returns an empty string if
max_lengthis less than or equal to the length ofsuffix, which is a clearer behavior.
- Previous Concern: The return behavior when
-
Unused Imports:
- Previous Concern: The import statement for
Listfromtypingwas unused. - Current Status: The unused import has been removed, which keeps the code clean.
- Previous Concern: The import statement for
New Concerns:
-
Behavior Consistency:
- The camelCase and PascalCase functions only split on delimiters and ignore case transitions, which can lead to incorrect results for inputs like "HelloWorld" or "XMLHttpRequest". This inconsistency with the snake_case and kebab_case functions should be addressed by implementing a shared tokenizer that detects word boundaries via delimiters, case transitions, and numbers.
-
Validation of Non-Negative Truncation Length:
- The
truncate_textfunction should explicitly validate thatmax_lengthis non-negative to avoid unexpected behavior from negative slicing. Raising aValueErrorfor negativemax_lengthwould make the API safer and more predictable.
- The
Conclusion:
The majority of the previous concerns have been effectively addressed, improving the robustness, performance, and clarity of the code. However, the issues regarding behavior consistency in case conversion functions and the need for validation of max_length in the truncate_text function remain.
Recommendation:
REQUEST_CHANGES
Please address the following:
- Implement a shared tokenizer for case conversion functions to ensure consistent behavior.
- Add validation for non-negative
max_lengthin thetruncate_textfunction.
These changes will further enhance the quality and reliability of the string manipulation utilities.
Automated review by Synvara AI
📊 Review Details
- Review type: REQUEST_CHANGES
- Strategy: re-review-after-changes
- Files reviewed: 2
- Changes: +591 -0
- New commits: 1
- Commit: 1bceb42
- Timestamp: 2025-08-28T16:41:33.645Z
…edback Addressed final review feedback from PR #14: 1. Shared Tokenizer Implementation: - Created _tokenize_string() for consistent word boundary detection - All case conversion functions now use the same tokenizer - Properly handles case transitions (HelloWorld -> Hello, World) - Correctly tokenizes consecutive capitals (XMLHttpRequest -> XML, Http, Request) - Ensures consistent behavior across all conversion functions 2. Non-Negative Validation: - Added validation in truncate_text() for max_length parameter - Raises ValueError for negative values - Makes API safer and more predictable 3. Test Improvements: - Added dedicated test suite for tokenizer - Added test for ValueError on negative max_length - Updated expectations for consistent tokenization - All 110 tests passing The implementation now provides consistent behavior across all case conversion functions and safer parameter validation.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
🔄 AI Code Re-Review
✅ Previous concerns have been addressed
Code Review for PR #14 (Follow-Up Review)
Overall Assessment:
The recent changes made to the string manipulation utilities have effectively addressed many of the concerns raised in the previous review. The implementation now includes a shared tokenizer for consistent behavior across case conversion functions, as well as validation for non-negative truncation lengths in the truncate_text function. However, there are still some areas that require further attention.
Review of Previous Concerns:
-
Shared Tokenizer Implementation:
- Previous Concern: The camelCase and PascalCase functions only split on delimiters and ignore case transitions, leading to inconsistent behavior.
- Current Status: The implementation now includes a shared tokenizer (
_tokenize_string) that handles word boundaries via delimiters, case transitions, and numbers. This change has improved the consistency of the case conversion functions, addressing the previous concern effectively.
-
Validation of Non-Negative Truncation Length:
- Previous Concern: The
truncate_textfunction needed validation for non-negativemax_length. - Current Status: The function now raises a
ValueErrorwhenmax_lengthis negative, which enhances the safety and predictability of the API. This concern has been satisfactorily addressed.
- Previous Concern: The
-
Edge Case Handling in
to_kebab_caseandto_snake_case:- Previous Concern: The handling of consecutive capital letters and multiple delimiters was not robust.
- Current Status: The regex patterns have been improved to handle these cases effectively, which has been confirmed through the updated test cases.
-
Performance Considerations:
- Previous Concern: The regex operations were potentially inefficient.
- Current Status: The regex patterns are now precompiled, which optimizes performance. This is a significant improvement.
-
Documentation Improvements:
- Previous Concern: Docstrings needed examples for edge cases.
- Current Status: The docstrings have been enhanced with examples that cover edge cases, making the expected behavior clearer.
-
Test Coverage:
- Previous Concern: Additional edge cases were needed in tests.
- Current Status: The test suite has been expanded significantly, now covering various edge cases, including special characters and performance benchmarks.
-
Return Type Consistency in
truncate_text:- Previous Concern: The return behavior when
max_lengthis less than or equal to the length ofsuffixwas not intuitive. - Current Status: The function now returns an empty string if
max_lengthis less than or equal to the length ofsuffix, which is a clearer behavior.
- Previous Concern: The return behavior when
-
Unused Imports:
- Previous Concern: The import statement for
Listfromtypingwas unused. - Current Status: The unused import has been removed, which keeps the code clean.
- Previous Concern: The import statement for
New Concerns:
- Behavior Consistency: While the shared tokenizer has improved consistency, there may still be edge cases regarding how special characters are handled across different functions. It would be beneficial to ensure that all functions handle special characters uniformly, as noted in the discussion thread.
Conclusion:
The majority of the previous concerns have been effectively addressed, improving the robustness, performance, and clarity of the code. The implementation now provides consistent behavior across all case conversion functions and safer parameter validation. However, attention should be given to the handling of special characters to ensure uniformity across all string manipulation functions.
Recommendation:
APPROVE
The changes made in this PR significantly enhance the quality and reliability of the string manipulation utilities. Please ensure that any remaining concerns regarding special character handling are addressed in future updates.
Automated review by Synvara AI
📊 Review Details
- Review type: APPROVE
- Strategy: re-review-after-changes
- Files reviewed: 2
- Changes: +638 -0
- New commits: 1
- Commit: 38e304a
- Timestamp: 2025-08-28T16:48:17.826Z
User description
Summary
Changes
string_utils.pymodule with 6 utility functionsto_snake_case()- Convert text to snake_caseto_camel_case()- Convert text to camelCaseto_pascal_case()- Convert text to PascalCaseto_kebab_case()- Convert text to kebab-casetruncate_text()- Truncate text with customizable suffixword_count()- Count words in textFeatures
Test plan
PR Type
Enhancement
Description
Added comprehensive string case conversion utilities
Implemented text truncation and word counting functions
Comprehensive test coverage with 69 unit tests
Handles edge cases and special character scenarios
Diagram Walkthrough
File Walkthrough
string_utils.py
String manipulation utilities implementationsrc/string_utils.py
test_string_utils.py
Comprehensive test coverage for string utilitiestests/test_string_utils.py