Skip to content

Conversation

@codecov-ai
Copy link

@codecov-ai codecov-ai bot commented May 15, 2025

This PR adds tests for #4

Commits:

  • Add comprehensive unit tests for smiles module including new glasses function

@lindsayrpiper
Copy link
Owner

@sentry-seer review

@lindsayrpiper
Copy link
Owner

@sentry review

@seer-by-sentry
Copy link

On it! We are reviewing the PR and will provide feedback shortly.

@seer-by-sentry
Copy link

PR Description

This pull request refactors the testing approach for the smiles module. The original test was a simple assertion, and this PR replaces it with a comprehensive suite of tests using the unittest framework. The goal is to improve the reliability and maintainability of the tests, ensuring that the smiles module functions as expected.

Click to see more

Key Technical Changes

The key technical changes include: 1) Replacing the single assert statement with a unittest.TestCase class. 2) Adding individual test methods for each emoticon function (smile, laugh, cry, tongue, glasses). 3) Using self.assertEqual for more explicit and informative test assertions. 4) Changing the import statement from importing a Smiles class to importing a smiles module.

Architecture Decisions

The architectural decision was to adopt the standard unittest framework for testing. This provides a structured and organized way to define and run tests, making it easier to add new tests, group related tests, and generate test reports. This aligns with standard Python testing practices.

Dependencies and Interactions

This change only affects the test_smiles.py file and the way the smiles module is tested. It does not introduce any new dependencies or interact with other parts of the system. It assumes the existence of a smiles module with functions smile, laugh, cry, tongue, and glasses.

Risk Considerations

The primary risk is that the new tests might reveal previously undetected bugs in the smiles module. However, this is a positive outcome, as it improves the overall quality of the code. Another consideration is ensuring that the tests are comprehensive enough to cover all possible scenarios and edge cases. The import statement should be checked to ensure it correctly imports the smiles module.

Notable Implementation Details

The implementation details to note are the use of descriptive test method names (e.g., test_smile, test_laugh) and the use of docstrings to explain the purpose of each test. The if __name__ == "__main__": unittest.main() block ensures that the tests can be run directly from the command line.

Comment on lines +5 to +23
def test_smile(self):
"""Test that smile function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.smile(), ":)")

def test_smile():
assert Smiles.smile() == ":)"
def test_laugh(self):
"""Test that laugh function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.laugh(), ":D")

def test_cry(self):
"""Test that cry function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.cry(), ":'(")

def test_tongue(self):
"""Test that tongue function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.tongue(), ":P")

def test_glasses(self):
"""Test that glasses function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.glasses(), "8)")

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Consider grouping related test methods and adding setUp/tearDown methods if needed for test isolation. Also, consider adding edge case tests or error condition tests to make the test suite more robust.

Suggested change
def test_smile(self):
"""Test that smile function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.smile(), ":)")
def test_smile():
assert Smiles.smile() == ":)"
def test_laugh(self):
"""Test that laugh function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.laugh(), ":D")
def test_cry(self):
"""Test that cry function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.cry(), ":'(")
def test_tongue(self):
"""Test that tongue function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.tongue(), ":P")
def test_glasses(self):
"""Test that glasses function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.glasses(), "8)")
def setUp(self):
"""Set up test fixtures before each test method."""
pass
def test_smile(self):
"""Test that smile function returns the correct emoticon"""
result = smiles.smile()
self.assertIsInstance(result, str)
self.assertEqual(result, ":)")

Comment on lines 8 to +23

def test_smile():
assert Smiles.smile() == ":)"
def test_laugh(self):
"""Test that laugh function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.laugh(), ":D")

def test_cry(self):
"""Test that cry function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.cry(), ":'(")

def test_tongue(self):
"""Test that tongue function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.tongue(), ":P")

def test_glasses(self):
"""Test that glasses function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.glasses(), "8)")

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

The test methods are well-structured, but consider adding negative test cases or boundary conditions. For instance, test what happens if the functions are called with unexpected parameters (if they accept any).

Suggested change
def test_smile():
assert Smiles.smile() == ":)"
def test_laugh(self):
"""Test that laugh function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.laugh(), ":D")
def test_cry(self):
"""Test that cry function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.cry(), ":'(")
def test_tongue(self):
"""Test that tongue function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.tongue(), ":P")
def test_glasses(self):
"""Test that glasses function returns the correct emoticon"""
self.assertEqual(smiles.glasses(), "8)")
def test_all_functions_return_strings(self):
"""Test that all emoticon functions return string types"""
functions = [smiles.smile, smiles.laugh, smiles.cry, smiles.tongue, smiles.glasses]
for func in functions:
with self.subTest(func=func.__name__):
result = func()
self.assertIsInstance(result, str)
self.assertTrue(len(result) > 0)

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant